Couple claim hospital mistakes led to death of baby girl


The Simpson Centre at the ERIBy Rory Reynolds

A COUPLE who underwent years of IVF treatment want to know why their dream baby was allowed to die just three days after her birth – claiming mistakes may have been made during delivery.

The couple – who are remaining anonymous – claim they were refused a second opinion and a caesarean section during labour.

They are also claiming that the forceps used to remove the baby girl contributed to her death three days later.

The couple have said that the experience has been “beyond their worst nightmares” and particularly devastating as they conceived baby Alexandra after five years of IVF treatment.

NHS Lothian and the Procurator Fiscal have launched an investigation but have also contested several of the allegations.They have said that the birth was carried out using standard procedure, adding that it was a “terrible tragedy”.

The 32-year-old woman said: “If it was the safest way to deliver our child then why is she dead?

“We have been told by the hospital that staff would do exactly the same procedure again and that we should actually feel sorry for the doctors, as they are really upset.

“It’s not them who have to walk past a room every day that was meant to be their daughter’s.”

The woman was first admitted into Simpson’s Maternity Unit in mid-June, when she was two weeks overdue.

The woman claims she was in labour for 40 hours – something that NHS Lothian contest.

Dr David Farquharson, consultant gynaecologist and clinical director of women’s services, said NHS Lothian are investigating the claims.

He said: “This is a terrible tragedy for this family and our thoughts remain with them at this very sad time.

“It will be even more traumatic and distressing for the couple because they had planned to have a home birth.

“The tragic death is being investigated by the procurator fiscal as part of the routine procedures for a death in hospital while our own rigorous internal review, which is also standard procedure in such circumstances, is nearing completion.

“We have already told the couple that we are very happy to discuss any questions they may have in person once our investigation is complete.

“I do not believe is appropriate to discuss this deeply sad event through the media.”

See more of our pictures at our Flickr site and videos at our dedicated channel,  Deadline TV.


  1. The medical profession needs a review of maternity practice. Doctors using forceps carry numerous risks that are not made available to trusting parents.

    Would doctors carry out such a dangerous procedure on their own children? I don’t think so. Forceps are a cheap, barbaric and last century way to childbirth.

    Doctors do not see the individual woman just another pregnant woman in labour. When the prospective mother is in labour doctors only see the cheapest way to delivery and DO NOT listen to the patient.

    Doctors are public servants but fail to realise this. They are on over inflated wages taking as much out of the NHS as possible but will deliver by a cheap and barbaric practice. Ask questions of the doctors and their flawed clinical judgements. You would be a fool to trust such a corrupt profession.

    Look at the latest case, Baby Parker Meredith-Doyle.

    Therefore experiencing their incompetence at the highest level. Doctors have apparently no accountability, code of ethics nor morality unless they are challenged in court.


Comments are closed.