Dispute over Royal Mile Whiskies stocking English malt

English whisky 2By Rory Reynolds

ONE of Scotland’s top whisky suppliers has become embroiled in a heated dispute over its decision to stock English whisky.

Royal Mile Whiskies in Edinburgh are to sell the English Whisky Company’s Chapter I next month after preview bottles proved a big hit.

But despite the approval of top noses, purists say they are appalled at the move, with one adding the firm have “betrayed Scotland” by stocking the Norfolk-distilled drink.

Arthur Motley, Royal Mile Whisky’s buyer, said: “We got some negative feedback, mostly from American Scots, said things like, ‘how could you?’ and ‘you’ve betrayed Scotland’.

“Some people were riled, but hopefully most of the comments were meant in a light-hearted way.”The firm that produces the ‘single malt spirit’ – which is emblazoned with the St George’s Cross – has also caused a stir by announcing that they will release a “commemorative bottling” if England win the World Cup in South Africa next year.


Ian Hudghton, the SNP MEP who has campaigned to ensure the phrase “Scotch whisky” can only be applied to Scottish products, labelled the newcomer, “not the real McCoy.”

John Kaylor at the Tartan Army added the drive for English Scotch was baffling.

He said: “It’s flattering that the English want to copy us, but what’s next, Shakespeare shortbread and the Lake Windermere monster?

“No true Tartan Army member would ever wet their lips with English whisky.”

But one whisky expert has said that the new tipple is worthy of sitting alongside Scots single malts.

Jim Murray, respected author of tipple tome, The Whisky Bible, said that the southern invader was a respectable offering.

He said: “Even without the peat, we have a gloriously characterful new make.

“This first dedicated English distillery for over a century is likely to gain a name for exceptional quality.


He added: “If any Scots start looking over their shoulder and get worried by this, then they must be hopelessly insecure.

“This is only one small distillery and it certainly won’t make a dent on the combined might of the Scotch whisky industry.”

A spokesman for the Scotch Whisky Association said that the group welcomed the move, saying: “The fact that countries outside of Scotland, including England, are keen to produce whisky is testament to whisky’s continued success around the globe – we wish out friends in Norfolk well.”

Andrew Nelstrop, co-owner of the English Whisky Company, reckons they have carved out a place for themselves already, with their distinctive tangy toffee flavour.

He said: “Much to our surprise and delight, our whisky has already attracted a lot of interest in Scotland.

“We are shipping about 500 bottles a month up to Scotland and we expect that to grow.

“There are a lot of Burns suppers going on in England now and we are hoping to supply them with genuine English whisky come January.”

See more of our pictures at our Flickr site and videos at our dedicated channel,  Deadline TV.

Short URL: http://www.deadlinenews.co.uk/?p=11089

Posted by on Nov 1 2009. Filed under 1, Scottish News. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

4 Comments for “Dispute over Royal Mile Whiskies stocking English malt”

  1. [...] Company’s “Chapter I” next month. The Deadline Press & Picture Agency reports here that some people think that such a move is “betraying [...]

    • Hi

      I enjoyed reading the above article and I am glad that our spirit (soon to be whisky) is being debated and getting noticed. I just wanted to make a correction though – Royal Mile have been selling our Chapter 1, an 18mth old non chill filtered single malt spirit and Chapter 2 which is an 18mth old peated version for some time now. Coming in December is our Chapter 6 which will be our 3yr old single malt whisky, which has been receiving some positive feedback that we are very proud of.
      I believe that competition is always healthy and whilst we are using traditional methods with no additives or colours, great barrels, water and barley we can only be contributing to the bigger world wide whisky profile.
      I hope some of your readers will taste our whisky and let us know what they think.

      Lizzie Green
      English Whisky Company

      • Good on you Lizzie and Olde’ England producing a Fine tasty Whisky
        i like to get a Distillery on the Mendips sort of Cyder Whisky lol
        …….manige gesawon garas syllan !

  2. As a Scotch lover I welcome a new malt whisky to try where ever it comes from. If it is good people will buy it and if it is bad the company will fail – it’s as simple as that. Penderyn Welsh Whisky was a welcome addition to the Whisky scene in Britain and Ireland, and has impressed many with its quality and flavour. Did this prevent anyone from drinking Scotch Whisky? – I don’t think so. I treasure my single malt Scotch collection, and would implore people (especially American Scots) to calm down and have a drink! Do those same people boycott American Whiskey as it was first made after distilling in Scotland had started? Was the same reaction made when Japanese distilleries started to make malt whisky? This is just a knee-jerk anti English reaction by a few vocal people. The English Whisky does not label itself as “Scotch” so it is not trying to decieve the unwary buyer in any way – as Ian Hudghton and John Kaylor seem to imply in the above article. Let this venture sink or swim on the merits of the whisky – not peoples prejudices.

Leave a Reply


Recently Commented

  • Father: Poor kid, :(. I hate it when it becomes all about everything else except for what the kid is going through. I...
  • richard: i cannot see how the management can get away with the very poor signage i would say its designed to catch...
  • PaulF: “Haggis is cheap, damn tasty, and very filling and nourishing” As and American who has eaten the...
  • Helene Oneil: Having read this article i wondered if this would go ahead in 2014 as i would love to go. My dad began...
  • Michael Cox: Do see a couple of disgruntled firemen on here saying these incidents never happen in the RAF Fire...