Scottish independence “unlikely” says expert on Quebec’s Independence bids


SCOTTISH independence is an “unlikely” prospect – according to a an expert on Quebec’s two independence referendums.

Professor Andrew Lecours – of the University of Ottawa – said the failed movement for Quebec’s independence is a good model for the current situation in Scotland.

The expert said that independence is now unlikely, and has told nationalists that they should not rely on demographics to secure a Yes vote in the future.

Speaking in Edinburgh – one year on from the failed independence bid – Prof Lecours drew parallels between the Scottish vote and Quebec’s referendum 20 years ago.

The referendum last year was a close race
The referendum last year was a close race


In 1995 – 15 years after a previous No vote for independence – a second referendum for Quebec’s independence was organised.

Once again, Quebec voted to stay in Canada by 50.5% to 49.5%.

Pro Lecours said: “Quebec independence is very unlikely now. Support for it is stagnant though attachment to Canada is continually decreasing, a minimal number of Quebeckers feel Canadian.

“I see Scotland in the very same place as Quebec – independence is unlikely.

“People feel a fairly weak attachment to the UK, but support for independence becomes stagnant.”

He also spoke of the “dying federalist thesis” – as it is known in Canada – which claims that because older voters said No, if nationalists wait for them to die they could win the next vote.

Prof Lecour said: “The thesis doesn’t work because as people get older they tend to favour the status quo.”

Previous articleTop energy boss slates SNP for “glaring inconsistencies”
Next articleGatwick courts Scottish vote for expansion bid