Referee Bobby Madden ‘brilliant’ in Old Firm debut, despite penalty controversy in Celtic – Rangers clash



FORMER top referee Dermot Gallagher has hailed ‘brilliant’ Bobby Madden for his debut in Sunday’s Old Firm clash.

And Gallagher reckons the whistler was right not to award Celtic a late penalty, despite insisting he believes Clint Hill fouled Leigh Griffiths in the box.

Celtic manager Brendan Rodgers insists his side were denied a ‘clear penalty’ in the closing stages of the 1-1 draw at Parkhead, with Madden also criticised for allowing Jason Holt to get away with a lunging scissors challenge on Mikael Lustig.

But Gallagher, who officiated in the English Premier League for 15 years and was FIFA listed for eight years, was full of praise for 38-year-old Madden.

He said: “I thought, for his first Old Firm game, the ref did brilliantly, I really did.

“He kept his nerve, he booked players at the right times.

“It was so easy to hook yellow cards out left, right and centre, which he didn’t do.

“It was a ferocious game at times and it was a great game to watch, because the referee took part in it, and took part as an equal.”

Hill may have confessed to Rodgers afterwards that he ‘got away with it’ when not being penalised for his challenge on Griffiths, but Gallagher agreed with Madden’s decision not to award a spot-kick.


Speaking to Sky Sports, he added: “I think it was a foul. But he [Madden] can’t see, he has no idea if he has played the ball or not.

“In that situation, he can’t gamble, he can’t give a penalty.

“The problem the referee has got is he can only give a penalty if he’s convinced it’s a foul.

“And he can’t be convinced. I feel for him.

“It’s a tough call. It’s the 89th minute and it’s 1-1. He can’t afford to get it wrong.

“In that case, he’s got to just say ‘I’m not sure, I can’t give it’.”


  1. Does Dermott Gallagher know that Mr Madden’s explanation for not giving the penalty was that he saw Clint? Maybe he should have waited until after the final whistle when the ref gave his reason for ‘play on’ to Lee Griffiths and Brendan Rogers when challenged.
    Oh and did Mr Gallagher see the two footed out of control lunge by Kenny Miller? Not even a yellow card. Was that another brilliant decision by Mr Madden?
    Why should a game involving the top team in the country be refereed differently from any other?

Comments are closed.